When it comes to dog training, a lot of confusion surrounds the 4 quadrants of learning—especially when people hear the terms “positive” and “negative.” Many assume that “positive” means good and “negative” means bad, but in reality, these words have nothing to do with emotions.
Instead, they function like a math equation:
Positive (+) means adding something.
Negative (-) means removing something.
The result is either encouraging a behavior (making it more likely to happen again) or discouraging a behavior (making it less likely to happen again).
If you think about it this way, the 4 quadrants of learning are just combinations of addition and subtraction with encouraging or discouraging behavior as the result.
Let’s break them down one by one.
1. Positive Reinforcement (+, Encourage) → Adding Something to Increase Behavior
Think of this as: Rewarding what you like.
In this quadrant, you add something the dog enjoys when they do a behavior you want to see more of. The reward makes the dog more likely to repeat that behavior in the future.
Example:
You ask your dog to sit.
The moment they sit, you give them a treat.
The dog learns that sitting = food, so they start sitting more often.
This is the most well-known method of training because it’s effective, clear, and builds a strong relationship between dog and owner. Common rewards include treats, toys, praise, or anything the dog enjoys.
✅ Best used for: Teaching new behaviors, reinforcing good manners, and encouraging confidence.
2. Negative Reinforcement (-, Encourage) → Removing Something to Increase Behavior
Think of this as: Taking away pressure or discomfort when the dog does the right thing.
In this quadrant, you remove something the dog dislikes when they perform a behavior you want. The relief from that discomfort makes them more likely to do the behavior again.
Example:
You pull lightly on the leash when your dog is pulling forward.
The moment your dog stops pulling, you release the tension.
The dog learns that not pulling makes the leash pressure go away, so they start walking more politely.
This method is common in leash training, pressure-and-release training (used with tools like slip leads and prong collars), and even basic handling (like dogs learning to tolerate grooming).
✅ Best used for: Teaching polite leash walking, teaching dogs to yield to light pressure, and building responsiveness to physical guidance.
3. Positive Punishment (+, Discourage) → Adding Something to Decrease Behavior
Think of this as: Applying a correction to reduce unwanted behavior.
In this quadrant, you add something the dog doesn’t like when they do a behavior you want to stop. This discourages them from repeating it.
Example:
Your dog jumps up on a guest.
You say “No” in a firm voice or use a gentle leash correction.
The dog learns that jumping results in something unpleasant, so they stop jumping as much.
Positive punishment can range from a simple verbal correction to using tools like vibration collars or spray bottles. However, it should always be used fairly and clearly—without overcorrection or fear-based training.
✅ Best used for: Reducing dangerous or extreme behaviors like jumping, excessive barking, or stealing food off counters.
4. Negative Punishment (-, Discourage) → Removing Something to Decrease Behavior
Think of this as: Taking away something the dog wants to reduce a behavior.
In this quadrant, you remove something the dog values when they do a behavior you want to discourage. This makes them less likely to do it again.
Example:
Your dog jumps up on you for attention.
Instead of reacting, you turn away and ignore them.
The dog learns that jumping doesn’t get them attention, so they stop jumping as much.
This method is commonly used in positive reinforcement training as a way to teach dogs boundaries without physical corrections.
✅ Best used for: Addressing attention-seeking behaviors like jumping, whining, or mouthing.
Putting It All Together
At the end of the day, all training falls into one or more of these four quadrants. No single quadrant is “bad” or “good”—they’re just tools that depend on the situation and the dog.
A balanced training program typically uses all four quadrants, but the goal is always to maximize positive reinforcement and use punishment fairly and clearly when needed.
Here’s a quick recap:
Quadrant | Action | Effect on Behavior | Example |
Positive Reinforcement (R⁺) | Add something good | Behavior increases | Give a treat for sitting → More sitting |
Negative Reinforcement (R⁻) | Remove something bad | Behavior increases | Release leash pressure when dog stops pulling → More polite walking |
Positive Punishment (P⁺) | Add something bad | Behavior decreases | Say “No” when a dog jumps → Less jumping |
Negative Punishment (P⁻) | Remove something good | Behavior decreases | Ignore a dog when they jump → Less jumping |
By understanding the math of dog training (adding or removing something to encourage or discourage behavior), you can make smarter training choices that are clear and effective for your dog.
Want to learn more about how to apply these concepts in real life? Book a training session with me, and let’s create a plan tailored to your dog’s needs!
Commenti